Skip to content
FactuallyVegan
Claim Reviewed
EthicsLogical Fallacy

The Claim

“Eating meat is natural, so it must be ethical”

Eating meat is natural

Last reviewed: April 12, 2026

Quick Answer

This is the "appeal to nature" fallacy. Many natural things are harmful (diseases, violence), and many unnatural things are good (medicine, cooperation). Natural does not equal ethical.

Evidence Summary

The claim: "Eating meat is natural, therefore it's ethical/good/justified." This is the Appeal to Nature fallacy: The argument assumes: Natural = Good/Ethical But this is logically invalid because: Natural things that are harmful:

  • Disease, parasites, cancer
  • Violence, infanticide, rape (all occur in nature)
  • Poisonous plants and venomous animals
  • Natural disasters Unnatural things that are good:
  • Medicine and vaccines
  • Cooked food (fire is a technology)
  • Sanitation and
...

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical or nutritional advice. Consult a qualified healthcare professional before making dietary changes.